Holding Vapors Of The Cci De L's Censorship Attempt Of > Cricket News, cricinfo, mobilecric, cricbuzz, livescore and more
Cricket news - Holding fumes at ICC's censorship attempt
Legendary West Indies pacer and a well-known commentator for three decades, Michael Holding, has lashed out at the International Cricket Council (ICC) for asking him to avoid pointing out the errors of umpires on air during the ongoing World Cup, calling it "censorship". Holding has told the ICC that the latter's stand - on asking commentators to restrain themselves from speaking about umpires on air - is precisely the reason why today's "commentators are being more and more compromised by controlling organisations to the point of censorship".
"I do not intend to go down that road," Holding wrote to the ICC in reply to a detailed letter from the game's governing body that he received soon after the match between West Indies and Australia on June 6, a game that the Aussies won by 15 runs. Both letters - the one written by the ICC to Holding and the latter's reply - are with TOI.
A certain Huw Bevan, the production head for ICC's rights partner Sunset & Vine Asia, wrote an email to Holding on Friday, June 7, with CCs marked to his colleagues in the production company, reminding them "the importance of maintaining the highest standards and uphold the game's best values and spirit while covering the tournament".
Bevan's email then goes on to add that ICC TV's duty is to reflect the values (above) and "not to cast doubt or negative judgement on anything associated with the tournament in our coverage". The email says: "Inherently in live television, there are occasions when on field decisions cause reason for discussion or debate, but as ICC TV host broadcasters, our (Sunset & Vine) duty is not to judge or highlight mistakes".
This came after Holding called the umpiring in the match between West Indies and Australia "atrocious". He added that field umpires in that game, Ruchira Palliyaguruge and Chris Gaffaney, had caved in to the pressure created by prolonged and repeated appeals from the Aussies.
Gayle got out to what should have technically been a free hit after Mitchell Starc landed almost a foot outside the crease while bowling the previously delivery. Holder was given out leg-before off Adam Zampa whereas replays showed the ball had been pitched outside the leg-stump. Holding was nothing short of scathing on air.
"We had an incident in the (WI vs Aus) match where we highlighted on air during an analysis segment (which Holding denies) that a no-ball should have been called," Bevan wrote to Holding, further adding, "this is exactly the kind of thing we need to avoid putting on air".
Bevan further says "Before the event, we went to great pains to explain to you all as senior production and commentary personnel of the need to avoid this kind of thing. It's critical for us that we should never amplify umpires' mistakes by giving airtime to those incidents nor show the umpires in bad light. We should also be very careful not to look to create controversy around an event or match at any time".
In doing so, he wrote that it was a strong reminder to everybody involved to "uphold the strongest of standards in our coverage".
Holding, famous for his plain speak, has certainly not taken this well. "If those umpires yesterday were FIFA officials, they would have been told to pack their bags and head home. They would not have been given another World Cup game to officiate. As a former cricketer, I think cricket should be held to a higher standard. Is the objective to protect the umpires even when they do a bad job?" Holding wrote back.
He added: "I am sorry, but I am not going to be part of that. Please let me know if I should be heading back to my home in Newmarket instead of heading to Cardiff because I don't agree with what is being suggested here and happy not being part of it."
It was indeed a scathing reply from Holding. For a legendary player-turned-commentator who refused to associate or identify with T20 cricket for its rampant commercialisation, Holding has been similarly scathing of the Indian board in the past.
"As I look through the list of recipients of this email, it would seem that I am the only commentator that has received the same," begins Holding's reply to Bevan, clearly indicating that his communication is only directed at Holding alone. "I was certainly very critical of umpiring which was pathetic to say the least," Holding adds.
TOI got in touch with Holding and the ICC to understand their version of these developments separately. Holding said: "It's true that there was a mass email sent out after the West Indies/Australia game and I did see fit to respond. But as far as I am concerned, the matter has been resolved and I have and hopefully everyone has put it behind them. I don't really want to distract from the World Cup that is already suffering from some uncooperative weather".
ICC sources told TOI "the matter is considered closed". It remains to be seen whether Holding will continue to be as outspoken.
Byrom stars on a curtailed yet absorbing opening day
Among the six who batted for Somerset on the opening day, only Byrom capitalised on his start. It is unsurprising that the Bob Willis Trophy final, being played at the ...
Familiar antagonist, familiar result for KKR
Rohit Sharma top scored with 80 for MI Chasing in Abu Dhabi was supposed to be considerably easy, if the IPL opener was any indicator. The pitch eased out for ...
Death bowling in focus as KXIP look to shrug off Super Over heartache
Mohammed Shami delivered a great opening spell in the opener against DC. A contentious one-short call or not, Kings XI Punjab have only themselves to blame for not being ...
Finch backs Philippe to succeed as finisher
Joshua Philipe got to face only two deliveries in his opening IPL game Joshua Philippe has the game to play as a finisher for Royal Challengers Bangalore, if compatriot Aaron ...
Live Cricket Score - KKR vs MI, 5th Match
How'll KKR fare against their bogey team? Do you have a question regarding this match? If so ask @ganeshcee on Twitter with#MatchFAQs and find answers hereMumbai win by ...
Abu Jayed tested positive for COVID-19
Abu Jayed will receive treatment in isolation for COVID as per guidelines and undergo further tests in due course Bangladesh's pace bowler Abu Jayed has been reported Covid-19 ...
Jason Holder replaces injured Mitchell Marsh at SRH
Mitch Marsh injured his ankle in the team's opening game Sunrisers Hyderabad allrounder Mitchell Marsh has been ruled out of IPL 2020 with an ankle injury and will be ...
A corner of the IPL's foreign field will always be South African
Faf du Plessis has been in impressive form in the IPL 2020, compiling a couple of fities Lungi Ngidi claimed three wickets in nine deliveries to derail Mumbai's ambitions ...
Zimbabwe Government approves national team's tour of Pakistan
Zimbabwe last played against Bangladesh in March 2020 Zimbabwe Cricket (ZC) have been given permission by the Government of Zimbabwe to go ahead with the proposed tour of Pakistan that ...
BCCI decides against renewing contracts of NCA coaches hired by CoA
The BCCI has decided not to allow the NCA to renew the contract of any of the coaching staff members hired in 2019 on a one-year contract by the ...